Hi All, having re-read the postings many time over, I have this theory. If the suspension knocks when it is on an extending stroke, there could be trapped air in the hydraulic circuit of Hydractive. To test the theory, there are a few checks. Has LDS fluid reservoir enough fluid? At any time did fluid loss happen? Joins on the hydraulic lines, are there significant wetting indicative not only of leak but also air sucked in? Are the linking pipe work in good regular shape not been smashed by objects such as stones? And if the Hydractive is due for service which is a fluid change, the work may be able to purge the trapped air in the affected part of the circuit. Small amount of air in the hydraulics will not show when in compression, but even a tiny pocket on fluid side of the damp gate can expand indefinitely (relatively speaking) causing the bang when the strud hides the limit of the stroke. Air on the other side, on the contrary, does not adversely compromise the damper function in this manner.